· Luxury Homes: We’re seeing an increase in buyers looking at luxury homes. There were several homes over $1 million sold this spring, and showings are on the rise.
· Sellers Fed Up: Sellers have lowered their prices so much, they often reject the really low offers without countering. It’s still a buyer’s market, but the sellers who have survived this long are becoming less tolerant of the bargain hunters.
· Fixer-uppers Back in the Mix: We’re getting calls for fixer-uppers, something we didn’t see much of in the past few years. They do, however, have to be priced very competitively.
· Depth Still Matters: Buyers are still focused on the depth of the water, but several shallow-water homes sold this past quarter. It will help when Google and others update their satellite pictures. Right now, they reflect the peak of the drought which definitely scares away buyers!
· There are ~ 60 lake houses under contract right now, so we expect the rest of the summer lake sales to be strong.
· Still Looking for Bargains: No doubt, buyers will continue to shop for bargains through the end of this year. Houses listed at the top of their value range may continue to languish on the market. About one in ten listed lake houses will sell, so the successful ones will probably be the best value available in that price range.
For those who follow the
As you can see in the following chart, most of the news is very encouraging. In the second quarter of 2010, 63 Lanier houses with docks were sold. That puts us almost to the level of the 2007 market peak which had 65 lake closings and exponentially above 2009 which saw just 27 sales in the same period. In fact, in all of 2009, only 138 lake houses with docks were sold. We could easily double or triple that number in 2010.
Not surprisingly, the average sales price is down to $444K, a significant decrease from the 2009 level of $506K. Many sellers responded to the difficult market by drastically lowering their prices. Most buyers are still looking for bargain-priced homes, and they are finding better houses in the lower ranges. However, we did see a substantial increase in the number of houses sold in the jumbo category this quarter. (A jumbo loan is 20% down plus a $417,000 loan which adds up to around $520,000 sales price, or anything above that.) There were 15 sales in that range, a 50% increase over last year. The average days-on-market before the sale was 121 – still high but way down from last year’s discouraging figure of 188. The percentage of list price to sales price is back up to 91% which is about average for a normal year. You can see on the chart that 2007 was extremely competitive resulting in stronger offers, and 2009 was clearly a buyers’ market producing lower sales prices.
|
Second Quarter Lake Lanier Home Statistics |
||||
|
|
2007 |
2008 |
2009 |
2010 |
|
# of lake home sales |
65 |
39 |
27 |
63 |
|
Average sales price |
$638 |
$577 |
$506 |
$444 |
|
Avg days on market |
96 |
99 |
188 |
121 |
|
% list to sales price |
95% |
93% |
89% |
91% |
Distressed properties (foreclosures and short sales) continue to impact our home values. Of the 63 lake homes sold in the spring, 15 were either foreclosures or short sales. Because these bargain-priced properties affect buyers’ expectations, most of the other non-distressed homes that sold were priced very aggressively to compete. Of the 500+ lake homes currently on the market, only 4% are distressed; but, you can be sure that those homes will be at the top of most buyers’ lists. Everyone is looking for a bargain right now, and buyers assume that a foreclosure or short sale will always be the best deal. That’s not necessarily true; and, as they discover the hassles of working with an institution on these transactions, that category may lose a little of its luster.
According to Lou Sarris, mortgage consultant for SunTrust, mortgage rates are at fantastic levels – at or near record lows. For lake home buyers who could not get financing in the past two years, Sarris says that jumbo loans are back, and the rates are much more affordable. Because mortgage insurance companies will no longer insure jumbo loans, buyers have to put 20% down on the house; but, the rates are closer to those for non-jumbo loans than they’ve been in years. To qualify, you should be fine if you have a 720 credit score; but buyers with money in the bank, a steady job and a score between 680 and 720 also have a good shot at getting that jumbo loan. We’re even seeing construction-to-permanent and vacation-home loans again. These are all definite improvements over the past two years.
If you would like to see what the average mortgage rate is on any given day, visit bankrate.com.
In the midst of difficulty lies opportunity. - Albert Einstein
I just attended the Atlanta Housing Summit, a twice-yearly event where experts share data, trends, and predictions about the metro-Atlanta market. If you read this blog often, you know that I am a big believer in the power of numbers. Whether you’re listening to a politician, a sales person, a member of the media, or a neighbor, chances are they are slanting the message in some way. With numbers (statistics, graphs, data), you can’t slant their meaning. They represent trends that have been observed in the past; therefore, they make it easier to predict the future. For that reason, I am a huge fan of this event where numbers rule.
I track statistics for Lake Lanier real estate, but this group tracks housing information for the greater metro-Atlanta area, including Hall County. For you bottom-line people, you’ll be glad to hear that just about everything related to home sales is trending in a positive direction. One of the speakers quoted a Case-Shiller statistic that said Atlanta real estate bottomed out in March of 2010. (Lake Lanier real estate hit bottom in November of 2009 and has trended up since then.) Here are some of the other interesting points from the summit:
¨ I knew that the value of lots has dropped, but I was amazed at how much. In many of the metro counties, lot price have dropped 90% or more. Yes, you are reading that right. A lot that was $100,000 at the peak of the market might sell for $10,000 right now. I don’t think they talked about why, but I can tell you. With so few builders building, there are very few buyers for lots. It’s Econ 101: when demand falls, so does price. In this case, demand plummeted and prices followed. This was too much of a fall, an overcorrection, and it is likely to be corrected upward if the economy continues to improve. For now, it’s great news for buyers but bad news for sellers. FYI, according to their stats, the lot values in Hall County dropped less, just 76.6%.
¨ The number of houses under contract has trended up for 11 months in a row. Historically, it had trended up for 40 months, then trended down for 35 months during the recession, and now has pointed upward for 11 months.
¨ The inventory of homes on the market has been reduced significantly. It is now at about the same level as it was in 2005. This means that every house put on the market will have a much, much greater chance of selling. Hopefully, this will make buyers less picky.
¨ According to Case-Shiller, the metro-Atlanta market home values dropped 24% since its peak in ’07. I think the national number is higher than that, though that wasn’t discussed in the summit.
¨ Resales are up for the third quarter in a row. Steve Palm, owner of Smart Numbers who gathers these statistics, was very optimistic about the 2nd quarter numbers. I think I heard him say it might be as high as 20%.
¨ Building permits are also on the rise. Builders have to be careful that they have the right combination of location, price, and product; but, it looks like the building industry might be starting its comeback – thank goodness!
¨ Another interesting number they shared involves resales versus new construction. Obviously, there hasn’t been much new construction lately which explains this stat. In 2003, the ratio of resales to new home sales was 5/4. Today, it’s 6/1. To be honest, I’m surprised the gap is not larger than that.
¨ Other interesting facts about new homes being built today: The most-often-chosen cabinet color is dark stain. Most kitchen floors in new homes are hardwood. The most common # of bedrooms is four, and three is a close second.
The other topics they discussed were somewhat political. Since I agree with them, I’ll share a few points and my thoughts. They showed a chart of what happens to the GDP when taxes go up. That has a profoundly negative effect on the housing industry. Conversely, when taxes are lowered (as in the Reagan cuts), GDP goes up. I wish I could show you the chart which illustrates that relationship in an effective, almost scary way. Bottom line: we need to vote for folks who will not raise taxes on anyone. A double-dip recession will not help the rich or the poor.
Finally, I just wanted to put in a plug for Steve Palm of Smart Numbers who is one of the speakers at the summit. He is a rock star in his world, and I love listening to him. My clients send me doom-and-gloom articles every week; but, the only numbers I believe are the ones from Smart Numbers. He tracks EVERY metro-Atlanta sale and has for several decades. Since I’ve been listening to him, he has successfully predicted many, many market turns that other “experts” missed. Any investor looking at a big project in metro Atlanta would be well-served to contact Steve at Smart Numbers first to see if the investment makes sense. He can save you millions (or make you millions if it’s a good deal). He doesn’t make a decision then look for the numbers to justify it. He looks at the numbers first, then evaluates the deal. I have a lot of respect for him. His web site is www.smartnumbers.com.
I’ll be posting 2nd quarter stats in July. Meanwhile, see ya on the lake! ~ Bev
Lanier is up and so are lake home sales
The statistics for first quarter Lake Lanier home sales are in, and there are many encouraging signs. Even though it was a cold, dreary season, lake home sales are up 30% over the same period in 2009. As always, Gainesville and Cumming are the most popular cities for buyers, but we saw a resurgence in sales for Dawsonville this quarter – from only one in 2009 to six in 2010.
From January through March of this year, there was very little activity in luxury home sales. The highest price home sold for $650K. The average sales price also dropped from $424K in 2009 to $364K in 2010. That is not a surprise since there were no higher-priced homes sold.
One of the most encouraging statistics was the number of days on market for homes that sold in the first quarter. Last year, it was 123; but in Q1 of 2010, that number dropped to 108. Not only does this reflect an improvement in the market, but it also shows that sellers are pricing their homes more competitively to start.
Subjectively, we are seeing a lot more competition on the most aggressively-priced lake homes. Homes that have been on the market for over a year are starting to move. As spring gets into full bloom, there is likely to be an increase in higher-priced home sales. We are already getting those calls. As the interest rates rise, buyers seem to be a little more action-oriented and reasonable with their expectations. Buyers who have been unable to “pull the trigger” have missed out on some of the best deals in years. They are learning those lessons and acting more decisively.
The top of the lake market was September of 2007. Most lake agents agree that the bottom was October of 2009. The following table shows some of the important first quarter trends during that period:
|
Year |
Total lake homes w/ docks sold |
Average sales price |
Highest price home sold |
% of sales price to list |
Days on market |
|
2007 |
50 |
$614,521 |
$1,550,000 |
96% |
85 |
|
2008 |
28 |
$622,035 |
$1,650,000 |
92% |
110 |
|
2009 |
23 |
$424,047 |
$973,000 |
82% |
123 |
|
2010 |
30 |
$363,840 |
$650,000 |
90% |
108 |